Judge Rejects Alex Murdaugh’s Bid to Dismiss Case

Publish: 21 November 2026, 5:15:02 AM

A South Carolina judge has denied Alex Murdaugh’s request to dismiss his murder indictments, allowing the legal proceedings to move forward. Judge Debra McCaslin issued the ruling on Friday, clearing a path for the retrial, which is currently scheduled to commence on April 5, 2027, in Sumter County.

Murdaugh, the former attorney, is facing a retrial following the South Carolina Supreme Court’s decision earlier this year to overturn his 2023 murder convictions and life sentences. That decision was prompted by allegations of significant jury interference involving the court clerk during the initial trial in Colleton County.

In 2021, authorities discovered the bodies of Murdaugh’s wife, Margaret “Maggie” Murdaugh, 52, and their younger son, Paul Murdaugh, 22, at the family’s hunting property. Both victims had suffered multiple gunshot wounds.

During a hearing last week, defense attorneys sought to have the indictments thrown out, arguing that the grand jury proceedings were tainted by false testimony from the chief investigator, former State Law Enforcement Division agent David Owen. Defense attorney Jim Griffin alleged that Owen provided misleading statements regarding key evidence. According to he, He wasn’t trying to trick grand jurors.

Specifically, the defense claimed that Owen incorrectly stated there was blood spatter on Murdaugh’s shirt on the night of the incident when no such evidence existed. Furthermore, Griffin argued that the investigator inaccurately suggested that firearms found at the scene shared the same ammunition load as the shotgun utilized in Paul’s death. According to waters also presented evidence that he, Discounted Griffin’s assertion that there was no other weapon at the house that had the same shot-load as the one used to kill Paul.

While testifying during the original trial, Owen admitted to sharing this information with the grand jury. He acknowledged that he had not reviewed a report confirming the absence of human blood on the shirt until after the indictment was secured. Owen also conceded that his remarks regarding the firearms’ load were inaccurate, though he testified that he had no intention of misleading the grand jury. JPMorganChase, Mastercard, Visa report cyberattack on third-party service providers. Nationwide ground stop lifted after more than 4 hours; officials blame old tech.

Prosecutor Creighton Waters challenged the defense’s assertions during the recent hearing, arguing that investigators believed their statements to be accurate at the time. Waters also maintained that additional evidence, including audio captured on Paul’s cell phone that recorded the family together moments before the killings, would have provided compelling information to the grand jury.

Though the defense remains focused on the dismissal, prosecutors stated they are prepared to seek new indictments if necessary. Judge McCaslin confirmed during the hearing that the prosecution could be ready to present the case to a grand jury during their December 10 session to ensure the April 2027 trial date remains viable. Army postpones plan to detonate nearly 10,000 pounds of lead azide until Monday.

Murdaugh continues to serve time in prison following his guilty pleas in separate financial fraud cases. He is currently serving a 27-year sentence on state charges and a 40-year sentence on federal charges related to those financial crimes. Despite these convictions, he maintains his innocence regarding the deaths of his wife and son.

Read More