People who have a history of dishonesty often continue to lie, even when under oath or while staring directly into someone’s eyes. While this behavior is perhaps not surprising, the current cultural climate, where echo chambers often obscure reality, makes it easier for misinformation to gain influence. The growing tendency to justify actions through the lens of one’s personal “my truth” has become a red flag that often signals a departure from factual accountability. They even, on occasion, fail to tell the truth despite having sworn to do so – in court, for instance, or staring deeply into the eyes of someone who is sitting right there. We all engage in versions of such behaviour every day. We understand that the current climate of mutually clueless echo chambers helps claptrap gain traction.
The documentaryYou Can See Everythingoperates within this framework of artful naivety. In a bid to explore whether Elizabeth Holmes—the founder of the now-defunct medical technology firm Theranos—is truly the victim of a judicial miscarriage as she claims, filmmaker Nathan Fielder spent several weeks living in the annex of her home. This period of access occurred shortly before she began serving an 11-year prison sentence for fraud. “You can see everything,” she promises him brightly, juggling babies and her godawful boyfriend.
Holmes famously promised Fielder that he would be able to “see everything” during his stay, even as she juggled childcare and personal relationships. However, Fielder largely ignored the concrete evidence surrounding the Theranos scandal. He chose not to investigate the court records or the detailed findings that led to her conviction. Beyond a pedantic discussion regarding the definition of the word “can,” he avoided questioning Holmes about the specifics of her deceptive practices. So Fielder duly blinkers up and blinds himself to anything concrete.
Instead, Fielder utilized an approach centered on reading her emotional state. He frequently engaged in intense, close-up exchanges, looking deep into her eyes and questioning whether she was “for real.” While the intimate, pore-focused cinematography creates a compelling aesthetic that sits on the thin line between profundity and banality, the methodology itself remains highly controversial. But we can still recognise the difference between little white lies and big red flags.
The film essentially rejects the notion of an objective, agreed-upon reality, which many critics argue is a dangerous approach at a time when shared truth is already under threat. We know that the moment anyone starts using the phrase “my truth” it’s time to cancel the wedding.
By prioritizing a “vibes-check” over forensic journalism, the documentary arguably represents a subtle but significant assault on objective fact. It stands as a profound dismissal of the judicial process and the experiences of those harmed by Theranos—not only the wealthy investors who suffered financial loss but the many individuals who received inaccurate medical test results from Holmes’s faulty equipment.
The film’s tone often feels uncomfortable, particularly when the narrative drifts into suggestions of a potential, mutual fascination between the subject and the director. These moments of flirtation or intimacy hover unhelpfully over the reality of the criminal consequences Holmes faced. Ultimately, the complex and grim story of a major fraud case is compressed into a vehicle for existential musings about identity and authenticity.
This reliance on emotional resonance rather than factual investigation may explain the film’s success with audiences who share a growing collective indifference to objective data. By tapping into a cultural zeitgeist that favors feelings over evidenceYou Can See Everythingpresents a chilling reflection of how we now navigate truth in the modern era.










