The selection process for the next United Nations secretary general is approaching a pivotal juncture this Friday. A crucial Security Council vote is expected to clarify whether the leading candidate, Rebeca Grynspan of Costa Rica, faces obstruction from the permanent five (P5) members. Should a formal block occur, the resulting impasse is set to reopen long-standing concerns regarding the disproportionate influence wielded by these core powers within the global body. The race to become the next UN secretary general could reach a decisive moment on Friday when a UN security council vote is likely to reveal whether the Costa Rican frontrunner for the post would be blocked by the big powers. Currently on the security council, will oppose her, as a result Panama and Colombia.
Grynspan, a distinguished economist and UN veteran whose family sought refuge in Costa Rica after fleeing Poland during World War II, has maintained a dominant position in the race. She has led in seven out of the eight straw polls conducted among the 15 Security Council members since the inaugural secret ballot on July 30. The voting procedure requires each member to evaluate candidates by casting a vote of “encourage,” “discourage,” or “no opinion.”
Although voters are not required to disclose their choices, diplomatic analysts suggest that Grynspan faces resistance from both the United States and Russia. While delegations rely on private intelligence and leaks to track the field, one diplomat remarked that the electoral mechanics prioritize the avoidance of negative votes as much as the accumulation of positive ones. In the most recent ballot on November 5, Grynspan secured 12 favorable votes against three negatives. A prior color-coded ballot on October 16—which distinguished between permanent and elected members—revealed two “discourage” votes from the P5, effectively functioning as a veto. But equally how many of certain votes you don’t lose.”, one diplomat said: “The electoral system means it is important how many votes you win. The logjam has to be broken soon, one way or the other.
The ongoing 140-day deadlock reflects a broader polarization that has complicated the tenure of current secretary general António Guterres, yet the persistence of the struggle serves to debunk assertions that the position has lost its significance. The ballot on Friday may also shed light on the campaign of the United Arab Emirates’ candidate, Lana Nusseibeh. Nusseibeh’s bid has faced scrutiny over concerns regarding the UAE’s assertive and commerce-oriented diplomacy across regions including Sudan, Libya, Yemen, Somalia, and Western Sahara. The protracted 140-day deadlock confirms the polarisation that has hampered the incumbent secretary general, António Guterres, but also belies claims the role is now an irrelevance. In the UK, the foreign secretary, Ed Miliband, has kept his counsel, but he shares a Polish-Jewish refugee heritage with Grynspan and cannot be an admirer of the UAE’s human rights record or its evasion of EU sanctions on Russia. The Chinese ambassador to the UAE, she also had a “thoughtful exchange” with Zeng Jixin.
Despite enjoying backing from Washington and Moscow, Nusseibeh has struggled to gain broad support, securing only seven “encourage” votes alongside six “discourage” votes in her two contested straw polls. Political pressure in the UK has intensified, with 68 Members of Parliament, including Sarah Champion, signing a letter demanding that Prime Minister Andy Burnham veto her candidacy, citing concerns that she is a “tainted and compromised figure.” Further opposition has emerged from Latin American states who, supported by China, argue that an informal rotation system dictates that the next leader should hail from their region. The prime minister, Andy Burnham, has UAE connections from his time as mayor of Manchester, and Nusseibeh is a fellow alumnus of the University of Cambridge. At the UN she worked closely with the UK in an informal group called “Friends of the Future of the UN”. Including the Labour chair of the international development select committee, Sarah Champion, last week signed a letter calling on Burnham to veto Nusseibeh, describing her as “a tainted and compromis, yet 68 British MPs. Since the last poll, Nusseibeh has been to Bahrain, Britain and Pakistan, a clue as to where extra votes may be harvested. And whether her active denials of UAE involvement in arming the RSF in Sudan leave her irretrievably tainted, the two hurdles are whether someone so deep inside the UAE inner circle would have the courage in office to show true independence. She insists she would make peace in Sudan her number one priority, from a Palestinian intellectual family.
The friction surrounding the UAE’s influence extends to other Security Council members. Somali President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud recently criticized the UAE for engaging in “dollar diplomacy,” alleging that the nation has moved to purchase ports and establish military bases without federal approval. Furthermore, elected members like Finland and Latvia have expressed reservations about the UAE hosting Vladimir Putin in December 2023, while he remained subject to an International Criminal Court arrest warrant. But Emmanuel Macron, the French president, travelled to the UAE in the midst of French riots to see the UAE president, Sheikh Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan, and secure 100,000 metric tons of diesel a month, the French foreign ministry may have misgivings about the UAE. The two elected members with the greatest stake in Ukraine, are unimpressed that the UAE gave Vladimir Putin red carpet treatment when he visited Abu Dhabi in December 2023, n, it is also possible that Finland and Latvia. But others deeply object to what they consider to be the UAE’s dollar diplomacy and preparedness to use its extraordinary wealth to exacerbate and exploit pre-existing divisions in a country to gain a commercial foothold. Greece, less engaged in Ukraine, may be more flexible.
Grynspan’s path forward also faces internal hurdles, including her age at 70, which some observers argue contrasts with a desire for generational renewal at the UN. Her age – she is 70 – could be considered a drawback among those calling for a younger generation to renew the institution.
Additionally, navigating the US political environment has proven difficult, with observers noting that US Ambassador to the UN Mike Waltz serves as a central gatekeeper for influence.
While Grynspan has downplayed her Jewish heritage, supporters speculate that her election could be viewed as a transformative milestone by the US.
With other candidates like Argentina’s Rafael Grossi facing Russian opposition over his work at the Zaporizhzhia nuclear plant, the pressure to resolve the stalemate remains urgent.










