Unveiling the Real Patricia Highsmith Through Memories

Publish: 16 November 2026, 4:46:12 AM

Publisher Otto Penzler recalls a 1984 literary event as a professional washout. Patricia Highsmith, then 63, had agreed to a reading at his store, The Mysterious Bookshop, on West 56th Street in New York. Having spent two decades living across England, France, and Switzerland, the acclaimed author of the Ripley novels was rarely seen in public. Penzler, who is now 84 and remains active in the field, had high expectations for the event. Instead, he recalls, only about four people attended. He describes the author as taciturn and uninterested in interacting with her readers. Then 63, had lived in Europe for 20 years – in England, then France, then Switzerland – and seldom made public appearances, so he had high hopes, the American author of the Ripley novels. Now 84, with a tidy white beard and a warm, amused manner, he is just back from a crime fiction convention and still very much in the game. So what does one do, i had a two-hour event scheduled. Whose job it was to take Pat to all the interviews, came with two long-stemmed roses, a young publicist.

Born in Fort Worth, Texas, in 1921, Highsmith achieved early success with her 1950 debut, Strangers on a Train, which benefited significantly from Alfred Hitchcock’s adaptation.

Her subsequent work included The Price of Salt, a lesbian road trip story published under the pseudonym Claire Morgan that sold a million copies, and the highly successful 1955 novel, The Talented Mr Ripley. However, by the mid-1960s, her success in the American market waned. Her agent at the time suggested her writing was considered too subtle and her characters too unlikable for the paperback market, leaving her without a domestic publisher by 1984.

Penzler, reflecting on his attempts to champion her work, suggests she struggled to maintain professional relationships due to her demeanor. He notes that while he signed her to a six-book deal, she was often difficult to work with, even rebuffing his small talk about France by declaring, “I can’t stand the bloody frogs.” Penzler recalls that her first editor, Joan Kahn, reacted with disbelief when he told her he had acquired Highsmith’s books. People got their book signed and left within five minutes. He signed a six-book deal with Highsmith, creating a new imprint in the process. “Pat didn’t want to be identified as a mystery writer, so I started Penzler Books, not yet knowing this. Did she deserve greater recognition in America.

The author’s later years are the subject of Anton Corbijn’s new film, A Talent for Murder, which is adapted from Joanna Murray-Smith’s 2014 play, Switzerland. Helen Mirren stars as an aging Highsmith, with critics noting her ability to capture the author’s physical presence. The film is set in 1995, a time when Highsmith had been living in isolation for several years, following the end of her final relationship with translator Monique Buffet. Adapted from Joanna Murray-Smith’s 2014 play, Switzerland, a dying Highsmith is played by Helen Mirren, who nails her physicality with dark contact lenses, a wig and a way of seeming to make her neck disappear, in Anton Corbijn’s new film A Talent for Murder. By 1995, when the film is set, Highsmith had lived alone for years, ending her last relationship with the translator Monique Buffet, then 27, when she was 66. Which made life tricky for her champions, she hated publicity. She then ordered a beer and fell silent.”.

While the film uses fictional elements to explore her creative legacy, it incorporates authentic details, such as her collection of pet snails and her habit of keeping cigarettes in water glasses. The renewed interest in her work, bolstered by recent adaptations like Netflix’s version of Ripley, has prompted fresh discussions about her public reputation. Penzler remembers that during her book tours, he and his wife often had to take on chaperone duties because the author remained notoriously difficult to manage. Of course, though lovingly built on real details, from the water glasses filled with cigarettes to her tank of pet snails and the Bond villain bunker she designed, it’s a fiction. With Ripley recently remade by Netflix, but has the knife-collecting sadist become a caricature, the image of the misanthrope has helped keep Highsmith’s legacy alive. Penzler remembers that on one book tour, “my wife and I took her to our most beloved Italian restaurant.

Despite her reputation for being a misanthrope, Highsmith’s Swiss editor, Anna von Planta, noted that she occasionally showed moments of humanity, even if they were rare. By 1967, Highsmith had established a long-term partnership with the Swiss publisher Diogenes, which later managed her estate. This included 56 volumes of personal diaries and letters, which, upon being filed, revealed her antisemitism and racist views. Highsmith’s Swiss editor, Anna von Planta, recalled a similar first encounter in 1984: “Pat greeted me coolly, disregarding my extended hand. In 2021, Von Planta writes that Highsmith’s views have been represented faithfully, even where offensive, but that “in a handful of more extreme instances [we did] feel, in her introduction to a published edition of them. If there was antisemitism in her stories, I probably missed it because it was mild compared to the other things.”.

Others who worked with her recall a different side of the author. Gary Fisketjon, her final American editor at Atlantic and then Knopf, maintained a positive relationship with her until his own death on 7 November at age 72. Fisketjon noted that they never had a cross word and shared a mutual interest in cats. He described her as observant and captivated by the world around her, particularly during a dinner at the Odeon in New York. Fisketjon published her works Found in the Street in 1987 and the final Ripley novel, Ripley Under Water, in 1991. With some authors, I can say, ‘Let me buy you dinner. “She never found a home because she was so unpleasant,” Penzler says. “I don’t think anybody said, ‘Oh look, we’re losing money but I love her so much, let’s keep her. Unrequited love and a poisonous mother, happiness largely eluded her, tortured by her sexuality.

Liz Calder, who worked with Highsmith at Bloomsbury during the late 1980s, remembers the author as a singular and unusual individual. In a 1992 diary entry, Highsmith noted a dinner in Hampstead with Calder and her pet parrot, Jon-Jon. Reflecting on their interactions, Calder recalls that the author seemed to share a genuine connection with the bird, often appearing more interested in its company than in human conversation.

The enduring appeal of Highsmith’s writing often centers on her technical brilliance. Agent and editor Weil notes that her ability to deliver emotionally jarring endings in short fiction was unparalleled. He believes that collections like the 2002 compilation, Nothing That Meets the Eye, contain several stories, such as A Girl Like Phyl, that could serve as the basis for future screenplays. Even those critics who condemned her personal prejudices often acknowledged her profound talent for character study and the precise, dark atmosphere of her prose.

Read More