Could Fatherhood Be the Secret to a More Peaceful World?

Publish: 17 November 2026, 10:46:37 PM

In 2014, anthropologist Sarah Blaffer Hrdy conducted an unusual experiment involving her husband, Dan. Upon his arrival in New York following the birth of their first grandchild, she handed him a vial. Hrdy wanted to determine if, like her own oxytocin levels—which had spiked by 63% after hours of cuddling the newborn—her husband would experience a similar hormonal shift. While it took a day longer for his levels to rise, the results were consistent. In her latest workFather Time: A Natural History of Men and BabiesHrdy highlights this as the first documented instance of an oxytocin surge in doting grandparents. She wanted to find out if something similar would happen to his hormones, having recorded a 63% jump in oxytocin in her saliva after spending hours cuddling the baby. But “what we’re seeing in many developed countries is something very unusual for mammals that has astounded me as an evolutionary biologist – men completely committed to looking after babies with a tenderness that you think of as maternal”. She never gained anything like the name recognition of science writers such as Richard Dawkins, or the conservationists Jane Goodall and Dian Fossey, but while Hrdy is widely admired as an innovative thinker and communicator. Ideas and experiments, but it was a century before female scientists were in a position to counter evolutionary sexism with their own fieldwork. But the revisions proposed by Hrdy and others were not well received.

Speaking from her home in rural northern California, Hrdy explains that the concept of the nurturing, hands-on father was once dismissed by some of her academic colleagues as an “imaginary creature.” However, she observes that many modern, developed nations are now seeing a notable shift in paternal involvement, a trend that is biologically supported. Research has shown that, alongside elevated oxytocin, fathers who are actively engaged in infant care often exhibit lower testosterone levels, mirroring patterns seen in various other mammals and avian species. Wilson was an entomologist specialising in ants – and one of Hrdy’s supervisors – who went on to become a crucial populariser of the concept of biodiversity.

Neuroscience research provides further insight into this phenomenon.

Brain scans of men who serve as primary caregivers reveal distinct neurological changes that mirror those found in nurturing mothers.

Despite this scientific evidence, Hrdy expresses concern over cultural attitudes toward fatherhood, noting that the United States recently elected a leader who openly boasted about avoiding diaper duty. She remains critical of political rhetoric, such as that from Secretary of Defence Pete Hegseth, which prioritizes high testosterone, arguing that if individuals with normal levels take synthetic supplements, it could negatively impact their capacity for caregiving. Over time, help to bring about a less belligerent world, her hope is that the activation of such capacities could. According to “This is the country where 40% of us elected a man who brags about never changing a diaper, and we’ve got Pete Hegseth [the secretary of defence], who, We need men with higher testosterone. Your sperm count is going to go pishooo” – she demonstrates with a swooping downward gesture and laughs, if you have normal testosterone and take supplements.

Hrdy’s career has been defined by her efforts to dismantle male-biased evolutionary theories. After earning her PhD from Harvard in the 1970s, she challenged the long-held Victorian-era assumption that sexual selection was primarily a struggle for dominance between males. While she respects Charles Darwin, she argues that his perspective was understandably colored by the prejudices of his era. She points to the work of novelist George Eliot, whose portrait hangs in her home, as an early example of resistance against the idea that male-centric hierarchies were inherently superior. Between the spectacular nests built by male bowerbirds – his emphasis on male-male competition set up a sexist asymmetry whereby they were viewed as facing selection pressures from which females were exempt, while he recognised that “coy” females had some agency as choosers – for example. “I don’t blame Darwin for being a Victorian; I am who I am, an 80-year-old grandmother who grew up in Texas,” Hrdy says. “I am a fifth-generation Texan with a Texas accent – and I think you are hearing it because I am getting animated.”. Hrdy’s hypothesis was that habitat pressures and over­population lay behind infanticidal behaviour. She deduced that males and females were seeking advantages: males eliminated the offspring of rivals in order to reproduce themselves; females, who were much smaller, could not “sexually boycott” the aggressors without compromising their own chances, from this pattern. Low-status females, one of which managed to wrest a wounded baby back from the jaws of an invading male. “Think total warrior,” she wrote later, of this encounter, which supported the “grandmother hypothesis” that post-menopausal females have been selected to support younger kin – explaining why, in a handful of species including humans, females live for a long time after their fertility, hrdy also observed older. Not passive vessels, was the broader argument, that females are agents with agendas.

Her early research, specifically regarding infanticide among hanuman langur monkeys in Rajasthan, India, faced significant backlash. By observing these groups, Hrdy identified that infants were only killed by males new to the troop, never by their biological fathers. She observed that mothers would often engage in mating with multiple males as an adaptive strategy to confuse paternity and prevent attacks on their offspring. When she first presented these findings—which emphasized female agency and strategic behavior—she was met with intense hostility, and one senior colleague famously walked out of her presentation. According to but when she presented her findings, one senior colleague walked out. “People were saying I was crazy and stuff,” she says. “By now, it has been vindicated: infanticide by males under exactly the conditions I predicted has been, In more than 50 species of non-human primates. Hippos, wolves, lions, all these other animals do it; it’s not big news any more.”. Hrdy’s troubling specialism was not the only thing that made her unpopular.

The atmosphere at Harvard during her doctoral studies was similarly fraught, largely due to tensions surrounding Edward O. Wilson’sSociobiology: The New Synthesis. The debate over inclusive fitness and evolutionary adaptations often turned aggressive; in 1978, protesters even doused Wilson with iced water during an academic meeting. Hrdy navigated this polarized environment while also facing personal challenges, including family pressure in her native Texas to conform to traditional domestic expectations.

Her academic path was unconventional; she eventually secured a position at the University of California, Davis, largely because the institution sought to hire her husband for his expertise in infectious diseases. She continued to publish provocative works, such asThe Woman That Never EvolvedandMother Natureconsistently arguing that women were active participants in evolutionary history rather than passive observers. These themes have only become more central as she has transitioned to full-time writing. Neural circuits in the hypothalamus and amygdala were activated, rather than the much newer – in evolutionary terms – neocortex, when they scanned the brains of men who were primary carers.

Now 80, Hrdy reflects on the legacy she is leaving for her three children and five grandchildren. While she maintains a busy life managing a walnut farm with 70,000 trees alongside sheep, dogs, and a llama, her curiosity remains her primary driver. She acknowledges that her interest in human nature is partly fueled by a desire to understand the world her descendants will inherit. Despite her long career, she insists that her motivation has always been a fundamental, relentless curiosity to learn new things, a trait that has consistently pushed her to challenge established norms in biology and anthropology. It is hard to overstate how important this is, given evolution’s foundational place in biology.

Read More