New research reveals a potentially uncomfortable reality: roughly half of the people we classify as friends may not actually reciprocate those feelings. While this realization can be discouraging, Adam Grant, a Wharton organisational psychologist, suggests it offers an opportunity to reconsider our social networks. According to Grant, this asymmetry indicates there are many individuals who view us as friends even when we do not label them as such, meaning we likely possess more latent social connections than we realize. The thought might make you want to wipe your contacts list and start afresh. Suggests Adam Grant, the Wharton organisational psychologist and New York Times bestselling author of Originals, and Hidden Potential, but let’s look on the positive side. People with supposedly complementary traits don’t actually get along better or end up closer – whether you’re talking about marriages or friendships or work collaborations. But for me, writing this book, it set the stage for the importance of distinguishing between different kinds of bonds, the fact they don’t reciprocate feels depressing. In the west, we tend to build nuclear families and nuclear friendships. That’s a lot of burden to put on a handful of people.
In his latest book Vibe: The Secrets of Strong Connections in a Lonely World Grant proposes that we move away from vague, broad definitions of friendship.
He categorizes platonic relationships into four distinct types: associates, who share transactional ties and resources; allies, who work toward aligned goals; pals, with whom we have fun and share experiences; and companions. Grant argues that individuals can fulfill multiple roles, but explicitly identifying the purpose of a relationship helps manage expectations and allows bonds to develop more naturally without the pressure to force every connection into a rigid, linear progression from acquaintance to best friend.
Grant cautions against the cultural tendency to overload a romantic partner or a single “best friend” with all of our social, emotional, and practical needs. Pal and companion, even though we know, empirically, that puts undue strain on the relationship, we treat our romantic partner as our No 1 ally.
He suggests that building a “balanced portfolio” of connections prevents placing excessive, unsustainable pressure on any one individual.
This approach acknowledges that the traits we seek in others—such as playfulness, collaborative support, and compassion—do not always need to reside in the same person.
This framework also helps people avoid the common mistake of comparing current connections, such as “mom friends” or workplace colleagues, against older, idealized friendships that functioned differently in earlier stages of life.
Western cultural narratives often mistakenly promote the idea that opposites attract or that constant interaction is the primary metric for connection. Research, however, shows that true alignment in values, energy, and goals is far more significant. Grant notes that even when people have limited time—such as parents balancing work and family duties—they can sustain meaningful bonds through small, frequent check-ins. He highlights the concept of “pebbling,” a term inspired by the penguin ritual of presenting pebbles to potential mates, which involves sharing memes, links, or nostalgic photos as a low-pressure way to stay connected. Research shows that the foundational ideas of compatibility in western culture are at least partially false. And, although similarity does attract people together, it doesn’t bond them. Some people, if they’ve met you a second time and liked you, will call you a friend; other people reserve the term for a much smaller circle of people, whose whole extended family they’ve met, or who they can pop in and visit unannounced. A reminder of something you shared in the past: “I just came across this photo of us together 10 years ago, and I wanted to let you know I miss you.”, sometimes it’s a bit of nostalgia. It’s kept us close for the last – gosh – 23 years. As opposed to finding a different way of going about it: you could collaborate professionally, or sit down and have a heart-to-heart, without going to a bunch of dinners together first, that closes the door to a deeper bond. According to certainly in the US, if you don’t feel like there’s a meaningful, personal connection, the zeitgeist, Unfriend, unfollow, ghost, go no contact.
Modern social networks have shifted from densely interwoven community webs to isolated hubs with disconnected spokes, leaving many people struggling to find a sense of belonging. To rebuild community, Grant suggests that intentionally introducing friends to one another is one of the most effective ways to foster a supportive social ecosystem. He emphasizes that even dormant ties can be revitalized; simple, periodic check-ins or pre-scheduled plans can keep relationships alive even if months or years have passed since a direct interaction. As Grant warns is his habit – he explained how compatibility and constant contact are overrated, what we can learn from penguins, and the surprisingly simple step to building community, in an ebullient audio call – beginning five minutes late. In general, we overrate compatibility – and maybe reciprocity, too, if half of our friends wouldn’t call us friends, it seems that.
Addressing implicit expectations is crucial for healthy relationships, yet many people avoid candid conversations about their needs. Grant observes that a relationship in which participants cannot be open about their boundaries or desires is often little more than a charade. He encourages a more explicit approach to understanding one another’s roles in our lives, noting that while conflict can be daunting, it often provides the necessary catalyst to move from a superficial dynamic to a deeper, more resilient connection. By letting go of the pressure to progress every friendship along a set path, we can foster more diverse, meaningful, and lasting bonds. The trick, he adds, is to understand the part these relationships play in our lives, the wavelength we share and what they need to thrive. From “we know each other from school” to “we hang out outside of school” to “we tell each other ev, i think thinking in these terms frees us from the perceived pressure to progress friendships the way we did as teenagers. Because we’re more selective about our relationships in adulthood, I think we have this unrealistic aspiration that everybody we choose to spend time with is going to be someone we become close to.









